log burner Vs. Open fire
log burner Vs. Open fire
What are the pros and cons
-
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 16073
- Joined: Sun Oct 24, 2004 10:42 pm
- Location: La Herradura, Costa Tropical, Granada
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
An open fire is very inefficient as most of the heat goes up the chimney and all you get in the room is radiant heat - nice though that is!
An enclosed log burner is more controllable as you can control the incoming air. Many of the wall inserted ones have a fan which passes cold room air around the hot metal casing and back out into the room. On some models this can be ducted to other rooms.
I am sure there are other pros and cons but that is my experience having used both types here in Spain.
Sid
An enclosed log burner is more controllable as you can control the incoming air. Many of the wall inserted ones have a fan which passes cold room air around the hot metal casing and back out into the room. On some models this can be ducted to other rooms.
I am sure there are other pros and cons but that is my experience having used both types here in Spain.
Sid
-
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 2984
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 2:31 pm
- Location: Sevilla
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
When we fitted our log burner the Spanish neighbours were very impressed with the heat output and decided to have a log burner put in. Their living room and the whole of the house was very warm. Before that they only had the under the table heater. Then another neighbour who has built his own house had an open fireplace built, it looks lovely. The neighbours decided to change the log burner to an open fire, which looks lovely. They now have to sit almost in the fire to get the heat from the fire and the bedrooms are now not kept warm (they are off the living room)
So going by the comparison with the neighbours log burner (just a very basic one) and their new open fire, for looks the open fire is nicer (their log burner was ugly) but the log burner was far better at heating the house.
We live in a bungalow type house, and if we have a good fire going in the log burner the whole of the house gets warmed from the heat coming off the fire, as long as we leave the bedroom doors open
So going by the comparison with the neighbours log burner (just a very basic one) and their new open fire, for looks the open fire is nicer (their log burner was ugly) but the log burner was far better at heating the house.
We live in a bungalow type house, and if we have a good fire going in the log burner the whole of the house gets warmed from the heat coming off the fire, as long as we leave the bedroom doors open
-
- Resident
- Posts: 1103
- Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2004 8:36 am
- Location: La Cala de Mijas
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Another major advantage (to me) of a logburner is that you can light the fire, pop round the corner to the Chinese, have a nice meal, and come home to a warm house. No spitting bits of logs flying all round the room. Similarly it does not have to be put out when you go to bed.
Alan
Alan
Remember that everything that Fred Astaire did, Ginger Rogers did too; except she did it backwards and wearing high heels!
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Our open fire created a lot of smoke (in the room - we were kippered ) and no heat. I agree with the other posters, an enclosed woodburner every time, not only for the heat output and controlability (is that a word?? ) but safety too.
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
We have one of each and I prefer the open fire. May use a bit more wood on the open one but it is warmer. I have never found log fires adequate, my own nor in any other house I have visited. Although Alan's point about going out is a good one.
- hillybilly
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 2939
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2004 12:53 am
- Location: Estepa, Sevilla
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
I thought none of us could afford to out any more?
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Definitely the wood burner! We had an open fire for about 2 days before we got the wood burner installed! The open fire only heated the immediate area, and was somewhat smoky! The wood burner has the electric fan as el cid describes, and gives a lovely ambient temperature throughout, though in these extra cold days recently, we have additionally turned on our econoheat wall heaters. And like Alan said, you can go out for a few hours, knowing its safely left, coming back to a warm house.
(and if you do decide to buy one Pilgrim, let me know...i can advise where NOT to purchase one from, around here)!
(and if you do decide to buy one Pilgrim, let me know...i can advise where NOT to purchase one from, around here)!
vino, sol y aire, y seras rico como nadie
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Cheaper to go out than burn those logs
-
- Resident
- Posts: 1103
- Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2004 8:36 am
- Location: La Cala de Mijas
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
I am afraid that I am seriously profligate; I go out and leave the fire on.Cheaper to go out than burn those logs
Alan
Remember that everything that Fred Astaire did, Ginger Rogers did too; except she did it backwards and wearing high heels!
- redsoxbrit
- Resident
- Posts: 302
- Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2005 2:39 pm
- Location: Guadalhorce
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
We have a large glassfronted fire set into the wall, when the fire is blazing the fan comes on automatically and other times we can switch it on (but only when the fire is alight otherwise it just blows out cold air) - does anybody know how much this costs to run? It does a lovely job of distributing the heat from the fire through vents in the front casing and also the chimney breast further up but I'm worried I will be clocking up a huge electricity billkarandjon wrote:The wood burner has the electric fan as el cid describes, and gives a lovely ambient temperature throughout
-
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 16073
- Joined: Sun Oct 24, 2004 10:42 pm
- Location: La Herradura, Costa Tropical, Granada
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Fans are very low in consumption - the one in the fire is probably the same as a dim light bulb - maybe 25 watts.redsoxbrit wrote: does anybody know how much this costs to run? ?
Sid
- redsoxbrit
- Resident
- Posts: 302
- Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2005 2:39 pm
- Location: Guadalhorce
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Thanks Sid, good to know we can use it freely - one less thing to worry about
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Sids right. We turn it on before it automatically cuts in and it works a treat. If you watch the electric meter whilst it is on, you can hardly tell the difference from when it is on to when it is off!
vino, sol y aire, y seras rico como nadie
- hillybilly
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 2939
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2004 12:53 am
- Location: Estepa, Sevilla
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Just stumbled across an article where it says that a woodburner is approx. 10 times more efficient than an open fire.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/gre ... -home.html
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/gre ... -home.html
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Many thanks for all your replies, a wood burner it is then
-
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 2984
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 2:31 pm
- Location: Sevilla
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
I was in the neighbours living room today and the open fire was going and we had to sit right up to the fire to get any heat- I ame back, opened the front door (straight into the living room) and the heat hit me! Our log burner any time
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
I find it weird how you are always in your neighbours in all the posts
-
- Andalucia.com Amigo
- Posts: 104
- Joined: Wed Jun 09, 2004 7:58 pm
- Location: Beckenham Kent/ Alcaidesa
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
Does the log-burner have to be unconcealed to get the benefit of the heat. I mean is it best to have it 'Free Standing', or do they work just as well set in an open fireplace?
- hillybilly
- Andalucia Guru
- Posts: 2939
- Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2004 12:53 am
- Location: Estepa, Sevilla
Re: log burner Vs. Open fire
She sneaks in to sit by their fire when they go outkaty wrote:I find it weird how you are always in your neighbours in all the posts
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 22 guests